Once, a participant in one of my training courses — a business owner — told me a very curious story. She had hired a university graduate as a marketer. Everything might have been fine, except that he was very fond of listening to, reading and watching information entrepreneurs. A very commendable pursuit — the business owner was delighted by his desire to develop. But after a while, problems began: he was unwilling to understand and delve into the specifics of the business or the owner’s vision and needs. He repeated phrases and offered piecemeal advice he had heard, following the ‘science’ without taking account of the realities. His advice was sensible, but it was either unsuitable for her business, too narrow, or needed adapting to her particular circumstances, which he was unable to do.
Unfortunately, such stories are not uncommon, and lately there have been more and more of them. They sound particularly sad when they concern not an employee who is a fan of information-business techniques, but a business consultant or trainer. The cost of a mistake is even higher in this case. Again, unfortunately, this is not uncommon, because the market for information-business techniques is being vigorously and diligently fuelled by attracting people with widely differing levels of professionalism on the following premise: ‘Look — there is quick, easy money here, and you can have it. All you need to do is learn (buy) two or three techniques — algorithms — from us.’ The result is a mass of info-consultants and trainers seeking to make money quickly and easily, and ‘undervalued’ info-employees who cannot understand why their sound advice does not work or why their boss will not accept it. The outcome is dissatisfied, disappointed businesspeople and employers. So what is the problem — what are its underlying causes — and what should we do?
Let us first answer this question: are the techniques offered by information entrepreneurs really so useless? No, they are not useless. Almost all of them contain common sense and produce positive results. The advice, knowledge, ideas and recommendations are sound and applicable! But…
We are now moving on to answering the question: what, then, is the problem? It is like an aspirin, Suprastin or Nurofen tablet. You need to know in which situations (illnesses) to use it and to check beforehand whether the Client is allergic to any of the ingredients. This is precisely where we realise that it is this knowledge and these skills that are missing. But that is only part of the answer. The second part lies in the ability of the consultant or trainer (or employee, if they lay claim to a high level of professionalism) to think. It is not only knowledge that we value in a consultant or trainer; we can easily obtain that from any book. What we value is precisely their ability to analyse information, synthesise, adapt, transform, generate and create (if you like), and so on. So what is valuable in a consultant or trainer is their thinking. And this is not only valuable but also astonishing, amazing and fascinating! What processes unfold in someone’s mind, giving us a solution that brings together techniques, knowledge and the Client’s particular circumstances and needs!
What is headhunting? It is not a hunt for knowledge — in the age of internet technologies, most of that is readily available — but a hunt for the ability to think, for thinking itself! And this is precisely the trend of the present and the future!
Some companies and managers declare things that every player in the market knows, or can easily find out, to be trade secrets. Are these really trade secrets? No! What everyone knows is not enormously valuable! But how we use that knowledge is enormously valuable! How we notice that knowledge — sometimes even this presents problems — turn it to our advantage, and identify the risks and opportunities within it: that is what is interesting, important and relevant! What will we come up with, create, integrate, transform, and so on? This is precisely what is valuable in a consultant, trainer and highly professional employee! It is this, rather than family connections, that enables people to build successful careers and get more done, take businesses to a new level, become interesting and profitable, and set trends in their markets.
Returning to the title of this article, this is precisely where I see the ‘crisis in the information business’: not in the quantity of consultants, trainers, knowledge and techniques, but in quality — specifically, the quality of thinking.
And what is a crisis? It is not the end, after all, but a beginning, an adolescence, a stage, a turn towards a new cycle. I think that, over the next decade, you and I will all witness the emergence of new, original, effective and, importantly, Russian approaches to doing business, as well as some very engaging and effective consultants and trainers. As for choosing a consultant, trainer or employee now, the advice is simple: buy not only their knowledge but also their thinking; buy not just an encyclopaedia, but brains!
Tatyana Arzhaeva, TSC Development Lab