Scrolling through the feeds on one social network or another, I am amazed by the widespread bad manners of Russian people and their passion for spending time in the Karpman triangle (the roles are tyrant, victim and rescuer).
Let us take things in order.
The main reason why you should answer a question such as ‘How are you?’ by saying that everything is fine is embarrassingly banal... It is ill-mannered and uncultured to burden strangers, people you barely know, acquaintances and colleagues (in short, everyone except your closest circle) with your problems... It is unethical, ignoble, foolish and so on. Want to solve a problem? Go and solve it! Want to get something off your chest? A close female friend, a male friend, Mum and Dad, a psychologist, a priest! And in return you need to be able to offer a shoulder to cry on too, or pay. On what grounds do some people effectively ask everyone else to be a bucket into which they can empty their everyday and personal problems? There are no such grounds.
Yes, we have Russia’s dramatic history, the 20th century. But surely we can switch our brains on sometimes? And consider that what was an appropriate answer during the Great Patriotic War was already inappropriate and ill-mannered no more than 5 years after it ended. As for what is happening on social media now — well, that is a sad state of affairs altogether. And particularly sad on FB... It is somehow less pronounced on VK and Insta, considerably so... And this sad state of affairs prompts what is actually quite an amusing question: ‘Are things so bad for the authors of these messages that they have no close “friend” or psychologist?’
And now for the triangle of roles — victim, tyrant, rescuer. Naturally, the victim role is flourishing in every possible way. And there are people who throw themselves into it wholeheartedly — taking on the role of rescuer... Actually, friends, behind the rescuer role lies one of the deadly sins — pride... And that is only the beginning of the story of this role. Behind the victim there is very often a highly skilful manipulator, and very often one with full-blown infantilism too... So before believing the victim and rushing to rescue them, it might be worth asking the second / third party, and so on, sometimes... And that, too, is only the beginning... But the main point is that it is not a triangle at all... It is a circle!! And someone who was a victim can skilfully become a tyrant a minute later; someone who was a rescuer can become a victim; someone who was a tyrant can become a rescuer, and so on. So, friends, colleagues... Playing these 3 roles is our favourite national game... And this whole pandemic business is revealing it to the full. But again, even through the lens of this method, I find myself asking every time: ‘Are things so bad for the authors of these messages that they have no close “friend” or psychologist?’
There is a difference between a case study, a story, a parable, a tale, drawing attention to a problem that may have a wider social or civic dimension / resonance, and so on and so forth, and posting your personal drama, your life’s ups and downs on social media (someone fell ill, people fell ill, someone was sacked, people resigned, someone was short-changed, deceived, ripped off, conned, people got divorced, someone died, people died; in short, something went wrong). It is one thing to tell a story from your personal life with a happy ending. It is another to air personal dramas and so on.
Let us be well-mannered and cultured. And let us introduce some constructive national games in our country :) The Karpman triangle is not the only one, after all...
Tatyana Arzhaeva, TSC Development Lab