Starting from afar….
A manager’s questions and thoughts about employees:
— Does he really not understand?
— How come? Was it so hard to work out?
— How can anyone do something so stupid? Or come out with it?
— Why are they so thick?
— How many times do I have to explain? I have already said it 10 times!!!
— And so on.
A customer’s questions and thoughts:
— Not a salesperson, not a human being, but a robot!!!
— The same tired phrases — well, that says it all!
— What nonsense they come out with! And what ridiculous things they do!
— Is it really not clear what I need?
— Just listen to me!!!
— I do not need all your banal phrases! I know them already!! Say something that is relevant to me!!!
— And so on.
Getting closer:
Should we write scripts, instructions and procedures, or not? Should we implement them, or not? Should we train employees, or not?
In other words: TO DO or NOT TO DO?
Or HOW should we do it? How should we write them? How should we implement them? How should we train people?
We can write them, and we can implement them. Scripts, for example, are useful aids! Especially if they are well thought through, based not only on ready-made stock phrases and actions, but on a deep understanding of customer behaviour and human psychology, taking account of logical and emotional subtexts and consequences. Scripts, procedures and instructions help employees get into their work more quickly, start producing results, develop the right responses, and much more. Using them significantly increases employees’ efficiency. You create them once, yet sometimes use them for many years. Those same scripts will significantly increase sales, and this will come through better-quality work by staff. Scripts also help reduce the company’s dependence on an employee’s level of education and innate intellectual and emotional abilities. This matters in sales, for instance, a field that, as we all know, people often enter when they have not been taken on elsewhere.
We can also provide training… in techniques, tools, algorithms, rules and standards.
And in answer to the second question, whether to do it or not, I would say: ‘Of course, do it!’
But what does the title of the article have to do with this? The bit about ‘little bears’?
It has everything to do with the saying that ‘you can even teach a bear to ride a bicycle’. You really can! For a lump of sugar, it will dutifully turn the pedals. And it really will ride. But it will never understand why it is doing this!? That an audience is watching it, that it is entertaining them, that the circus is earning money, including money for its sugar — and there are many other things it will not understand….
For some tasks and types of work, we really do need ‘little bear’ employees. Their task is simple: turn the pedals and get their sugar. Perhaps that is insulting. Perhaps it is unpleasant. But they do it quite well.
But in other types of work, this will not be enough! Necessary, but not enough! In sales, for instance, especially complex, high-value sales (and, in fact, any sales involving communication with a customer), we need employees who are ‘NOT little bears’. For the simple reason that sales professionals repeatedly interact with a huge number of people… different people, each requiring an individual approach, which ideally needs to be found very quickly. Or take a manager, for example: every day, they tackle a host of different tasks. They need to find the key to solving each one, and preferably quickly too. This means that algorithms alone are not enough to tackle these tasks successfully! Memorised actions are not enough! Repeating what you have read or seen is not enough! Following a template or a standard is not enough!
Many people seem to understand and accept this. But… that does not necessarily mean they act on it. Yet it is precisely action, and the quality of that action, that provides the key test of whether understanding exists and how good it is.
So, a number of professions and roles require employees with well-developed thinking skills, specifically 4 types of thinking. And for sales professionals, it would be good to have all 5 well developed. In other words, we need employees who know how to think! Reflect! Reason!
And in answer to the 3rd question, I would say: ‘This is precisely what employees need to be taught. Scripts and procedures are useful aids, but not a panacea. An employee who is proficient in 4 types of thinking (ASEK), or better still 5 (ASBEK), becomes the company’s magic wand, its magician. Of course, teaching algorithms and how to follow them would be a good start. But we need to look ahead. And today, right now, we need to teach people how to think, or select people who know how to do so, especially for sales and strategic, key positions!’
The main point
Even in training courses that teach techniques, phrases and algorithms, we need to teach employees to THINK! Even within those same scripts, we need to lay the foundations for employees not to act by rote, but to !!! think!!! Build this into instructions and procedures. Otherwise, there is a risk that they will be unable to apply a technique, or to apply it where it is genuinely needed! Otherwise, there is a risk that they will be unable to devise one! Otherwise, there is a risk that they will be unable to handle an unusual situation! Or sometimes even a routine one! Otherwise, there is a risk (a real one!!!) that they may act inappropriately, talk about the wrong things, and find themselves in comical, or sometimes even tragic, situations. If only it affected them alone. Sometimes they drag their department, or even the whole company, along with them.
By developing an employee’s ability to think, and not just logically, we increase their capacity to turn the pedals, and not just on a bicycle… and to do more than just turn pedals. We reduce the risks I have mentioned. Among other things, we remove the reasons for the questions and thoughts (and many others) quoted at the beginning.
Today (and in the future too), thinking is (and will be) one of the important keys to success. Although… to be honest, not just today and in the future…
Tatyana Arzhaeva, TSC Development Lab