What are people planning to practise in training without theory?
Sales (like management, for that matter) is an intellectual activity that may involve elements of physical labour only in certain cases.
In other words, this work is closer to medicine, for example, than to knitting or simple lathe work. It is also work in which you need to be able to think, to think before acting. So it would be good to move from the approach of ‘act first, think later’ to ‘think first, act later’, to avoid ending up with ‘we wanted the best, but things turned out as they always do’.
Accordingly, learning an intellectual activity proceeds from knowledge to abilities, and from abilities to practised skills. In precisely that order.
With simple physical labour (this no longer applies to complex work), however, it is possible to proceed from ability to knowledge and then to practised skills, or from ability to practised skills and then to knowledge.
That is why sales training (management training and so on) must include knowledge (or theory, in other words) and exercises to develop abilities. Participants generally develop practised skills themselves in their everyday work.
Practised skills can also be developed during training, but only if participants have sufficient theoretical knowledge (which is often not the case) and some initial abilities (not always sound ones), which are then developed, refined and so on. But this route is generally expensive for companies, because practised skills are not acquired in 1 or 2 training courses. It is a long process — from 2–3 months to several years of regular practice, depending on the complexity of the skills required (forming conditioned reflexes takes time, especially in intellectual activity). There is no point harbouring illusions about this… Just remember how long it takes to implement intellectual technologies — new software or changes to it, new standards, rules and procedures, for example, especially if they are complex and all this happens without preparatory work.
Theory is the structured practical experience of many people over an enormous period of time, which makes it possible to predict how a situation will develop fairly accurately and to conduct fairly successful experiments in practice. No individual has enough time (their life is millions of times shorter than this collective practical experience) to accumulate that much experience. That is why theory is so important.
Hardly anyone would go to a practising doctor who knows no theory and will look for the liver by trial and error, perhaps because this is the first time they have heard of it. And hardly anyone would want to live near a nuclear power station whose staff are all hands-on practitioners with no theoretical knowledge of nuclear physics, or even of physics in general. In sales (management), the risks are, fortunately, lower, of course, but losing clients still costs both the company and its salespeople a great deal.
An important question in this context:
what will a salesperson or manager practise without theory?
What they already do, what they already know.
But then what is the point of sending them on a training course for that? Is it not rather expensive?
They can do exactly the same thing at work.
Now, on to practice. Practice takes an enormous number of forms. Some are stressful, while others are psychologically comfortable. Stressful methods are useful in certain cases, but even then it is important to understand their consequences and their effect on the overall learning outcome. The fact is that stressful methods reduce that outcome, sometimes wiping it out altogether. For example, pair work in which participants play ‘salesperson and client’ is stressful. Not all participants are ready to be listened to, assessed and criticised — however constructively, it is still in front of everyone (however much this is softened, that is still how it will be perceived), even if praise comes first. Even confident salespeople (or managers) who can talk anyone round may start to feel nervous on stage in front of a large audience of onlookers and judges. And many have had negative experiences of speaking in front of others and so on at school or in other learning settings. Some have a fear of public speaking.
Yes, in this stressful situation we will see every possible mistake a participant could potentially make. But can we see this through gentler methods? Yes! Managers and salespeople, especially those in proactive sales, already face plenty of stress at work. Do we always need to add more? Not always.
So this method should be used when most of the group will take it calmly and it will, at the very least, do no harm and, at best, be beneficial. Or when the group is very large and there will be no public exercises in front of everyone — participants work only in their pairs or teams, which is a more comfortable option for them.
Overall, there are plenty of forms of practice that are psychologically comfortable for participants. The choice is enormous… If only there is the willingness.
In any event, it is important to understand that the most important practice begins after the training. To support this, it would be good to draw up a week-by-week schedule for implementing the techniques after training, observing all the rules of this process. Yes, this too has its nuances that you need to know about. Implementation must be handled correctly and properly if you want results.
Tatyana Arzhaeva, TSC Development Lab.