Skip to content
TSC Development Lab+7 (383) 292-28-74
Menu
+7 (383) 292-28-74tsc@ts-consulting.ru
HomeArticles & InsightsHuman Resource ManagementWhat Comes First: ‘Bread and Circuses’ or Practical Value and Results?

Article

What Comes First: ‘Bread and Circuses’ or Practical Value and Results?

When meeting clients commissioning in-house or open training, we often hear requests such as: ‘Can you fire them up? They attended a training course recently and said they were bored.’ Sometimes they say: ‘My employees have already attended SO MANY training courses — how can you surprise them?’

Don’t you think that ‘surprise them’, ‘fire them up’, ‘fun/boring’, ‘interesting/uninteresting’ and ‘like/dislike’ belong in a rather different context?


Imagine that someone you know falls ill and goes to the doctor, then complains afterwards: ‘What a boring doctor. He didn’t do anything new with me — just took my temperature, ordered tests and examinations and prescribed medicines, like everyone else, like before. I’m not going back to him. He wasn’t much fun.’

In the doctor’s case, we would find our acquaintance’s remark rather strange: surely the primary aim is to make a diagnosis, prescribe the right treatment and cure the illness — in other words, help the person become healthy. Of course, it is good when a doctor does this cheerfully and with humour, making appropriate jokes, lifting the patient’s spirits and offering encouragement. But you would agree that if a doctor does nothing but joke around and put on a show, making an incorrect diagnosis or none at all and prescribing no treatment, we are unlikely to return. So why do we sometimes behave differently towards a trainer? We suggest reflecting on how to choose a trainer for in-house or open training, how to set the right learning objectives and which important points to consider, so that you do not later bitterly regret wasting your time and money.

First, let’s establish what we want. Some people want excitement, action, a show, fun and entertainment; others want practical value and results, substance, a systematic approach, and practical knowledge, abilities and skills. Those who want the former can confidently head straight to the right place: a wedding toastmaster or organisers of parties and entertainment. Would you call that rude? Yet we have just used one of the techniques for creating that very sense of excitement and action.


So let’s first recognise the obvious difference between a toastmaster and a trainer. They have different goals. The former’s job is to entertain; the latter’s is to teach. Anyone who wants to learn or resolve an important professional issue will look for a trainer, which means that they will focus first on the content, its usefulness, its practical applicability and the results that can be achieved. Of course, it is good and sensible for a trainer to make learning engaging, but it is important to understand that, as with the doctor, this is secondary.


Let’s also reflect on whether people should like a training course. If the specific aim of the course is for employees to like it, you can forget about results and consider the money invested in training thrown away. Why? Because the trainer will not be working towards results — you yourself have declared them unimportant — or you will find a trainer who does not think about results at all. Incidentally, a self-respecting trainer who knows what they are working towards will not agree to deliver training whose sole purpose is to be liked.

This ‘like/dislike’ approach can be compared to comfort in the workplace.  And that is right, since we spend a third of our lives at work. Many job applicants today say that interesting tasks and a comfortable workplace are key factors when choosing a job. And many managers today strive to look after their employees’ comfort. Sometimes, however, they become so carried away with caring that they completely forget that a business must, after all, make money and an employee’s work must be effective. Similarly, how interesting employees find their tasks sometimes becomes the key factor in choosing the organisation’s direction of development. Where does this lead? Among other things, to employees’ assessments of a trainer at the level of ‘like/dislike’ becoming the key factor in choosing one. It is good if people like the training, but the main thing is that it should be effective. To achieve this, a trainer very often has to do things that participants do not like at all, but which produce the desired effect. That effect will not materialise if the trainer is preoccupied with making sure people like the course. Development is not always possible within the comfort zone. Very often, employees — and not only employees — do not want to do anything to develop while they remain there; only stepping into the risk zone and receiving a magic kick up the backside spurs them into action that has long been overdue. And, honestly, not everyone likes the risk zone or a kick up the backside.

Moreover, it is not uncommon for people to attend training courses and listen to webinars and like everything very, very much. But that is where the story ends. They carry on doing what they have always done and fail to do what they should. Very often, a trainer who points this out and urges them to ‘think’, ‘work towards results’ and so on is seen as ‘boring’, ‘unprofessional’ or ‘uninteresting’. Yes, that is how it is. After all, there is nothing interesting about changing established, ingrained habits, especially when the boss is unwittingly paying you for them. Let’s also remember how we learnt to ride a bicycle. Surely there were falls or scraped knees, and we can hardly have liked that. But we did learn! Because we wanted to ride a bicycle! So perhaps some people find training boring and uninteresting because they do not actually want to learn to ‘ride a bicycle’?


Recently, the head of an organisation told us that he had long dreamed of introducing a CRM system that would let him receive real-time reports on the Sales Department’s work and also save the organisation’s accountant a whole working day each month, which she spends calculating the sales staff’s pay. The CRM system was developed and tailored to the organisation’s needs long ago, but… What is the problem? It turned out that the sales staff had flatly refused to learn to use the CRM because it was inconvenient for them, because they would have to spend some time and effort learning how to use it and making it a habit. Don’t you think things have gone too far when the needs — or, more accurately, the ‘I want to/I don’t want to’ — of an individual employee or employees take priority over those of the organisation as a whole?

Exactly the same thing happens with training: ‘I want to learn; I don’t want to.’ And sometimes: ‘I want to learn at this time, but not at that time’, ‘I want to learn if the training is interesting’, ‘I’ll learn if you get me interested.’ Some time ago, employees were selected on the basis of their professionalism. If you had the skills and ability to carry out the tasks assigned, you would get the job and be paid accordingly. If you did not — goodbye, next. Now an employee often applies for a job, especially in sales, with the demand: teach me and motivate me, and then perhaps I will deliver results — or perhaps I will not. And before you teach me, motivate me to learn as well. Why do you need an employee who is not sufficiently professional and who also sets conditions? Who needs their training? The trainer? You? Or, first and foremost, the employee?

Very often, the most persistent criticism of a trainer comes from employees and other people who are themselves afraid of public speaking, can hardly teach anyone anything and are far from effective. You would agree that it is strange to hear criticism of a trainer from an ordinary salesperson — no offence intended — who regularly misses their targets, criticism of a major business owner from a security guard, or criticism of a doctor’s methods from a cleaner who washes the hospital floors. Very often, it is precisely these ‘critics’ who, having watched a million webinars and attended countless training courses, say: ‘This doesn’t work — it won’t work.’ And they do nothing! They remain exactly where they were! So is it worth listening to such ‘critics’?

To conclude, let’s ask the final 2 questions: action or practical value, a show or substance, fun and surprises or knowledge and skills, liking it or effectiveness? What you will pay for first and foremost with your money and time is for you to decide. Which employees you will train and which you will not, who is worth investing in and who is not worth investing in from the outset — that, too, is for you to decide!

P.S. For more on how to choose a trainer and a training course, read our book ‘The 20 Most Dangerous Mistakes When Commissioning In-House Training’


Tatyana Arzhaeva, ‘TSC Development Lab’, Natalya Rachkovskaya, ‘Biznes-Podderzhka’

← Human Resource Management

Contact us
Order a book