Skip to content
TSC Development Lab+7 (383) 292-28-74
Menu
+7 (383) 292-28-74tsc@ts-consulting.ru
HomeArticles & InsightsPersonal EffectivenessDoes a business trainer have to be a successful entrepreneur?

Article

Does a business trainer have to be a successful entrepreneur?

On the hidden meaning of castes — what happens if we confuse or mix roles in today’s world?

An interesting combination of questions? For me too.
But as it happened, 2 questions were troubling me in some way. Not that I was losing sleep over them, thinking and thinking and thinking about nothing else. Of course not. You could say these questions came into my head a few times, and that was all. But that is how I am: if questions arise in my head, there will definitely be an answer to them.

So, what are these questions?
1. There is a popular idea in our country that a business trainer (who is also a teacher) must be a successful businessperson. This idea has been floating around our country for a long time. Clients commissioning training worry and look for a teacher with a business, although they also worry that this person might ‘steal’ their business idea and the business itself… Meanwhile, business trainers worry about whether they have a business, and how big it is, when negotiating with such clients.
As I reflected on this question, I realised that the question itself and the whole situation made me uneasy: I had a feeling that something was wrong here. Illogical.

2. Freedom is a very important value for me. At the same time, I understand and appreciate the role of rules and order when they are reasonable and appropriate, when they help and serve as a sound tool in wise hands. But not when they become restrictions, rigid boundaries, and start holding back and limiting development and progress.
That is why the caste system in India made me uneasy (incidentally, ‘caste’ is not an Indian word)… Caste systems exist in one form or another in every society; the question is WHO devised them. In this case, it was devised by people who seemingly should not have devised it… This raises the question: what was the point? Or has something happened to that meaning over the centuries? Has it become distorted…

The answer to question 1 will come through the answer to question 2.

Let me say straight away that any system can be perverted if someone wishes, even the most wonderful one. Perverted, debased, disfigured and so on. No religion, no faith, no political idea, business idea, corporate culture or company mission has escaped this. So we will talk not about what was done to it, but about what was intended before it was all ‘diminished’. Of course, since I have never shared tea — or any other drinks — with its authors, I can only offer my hypothesis. Although, since we are talking about India, we might mention reincarnation in passing, so who knows — perhaps I did share a drink with them. Milk.

So, let us think about rulers (the Kshatriya caste — rulers, administrators, warriors). A ruler serves his country and his people. But if he is also a trader (the Vaishya caste), he may sell his country and his people. Have we encountered this in history? Countless times! This clearly did the people and country of such rulers no good. But did that trouble the ruler-trader? Or the person buying the country, its people and its resources?
And what if an administrator is a swashbuckling trader? Well, corruption is guaranteed. Sound familiar? Selling a building permit or something else?
And what if a warrior trades his skills or weapons instead of serving his country, his people and his ruler? What do we get? A mercenary with neither honour nor conscience? The enemy has paid more, so shall we turn against our own? That is the approach of warrior-traders…
Have you thought about it in this context? Shall we continue?

And what if a ruler is a craftsman (the same Vaishya caste)? It is good for him to have a useful skill: anything can happen in life. That is why wise fathers or mentors did teach their children a useful craft (and in some cases rulers taught themselves). But if he forgets his primary role and switches his priorities, once again it will do the country and its people no good. He should develop crafts and help people in this way, but should not spend all his time practising a craft himself. Setting sensible priorities — what should come first if you are a ruler? The people, the country or the craft?

We can extend the analogy to the administrator and the warrior (from that Kshatriya caste).

Now let us talk about traders (Vaishyas). If our dear trader displays military qualities very strongly, what will happen? A war for markets and unfair competition using grey and black methods? This too has happened in history. The consequences are well known. What is more, we are seeing all this today, on a global scale.
And what if our charming trader wants power? And becomes a ruler (on a small or large scale)? Oh, what a painfully familiar situation! When a major businessperson enters politics… Why? Quite right — to lobby for his own interests, those of his trading business or craft (if he is a craftsman)… What is the outcome? Very often, the result is not very good, because human beings are, for the most part, weak creatures.

What do you think of these ideas?

But we still have 2 castes left. Shudras — workers, and Brahmins — priests, who are also bearers of knowledge, in other words teachers, or, in modern terms, business trainers, since every caste has many manifestations and levels (steps towards mastery)!

First, about workers. If a ruler, for example a mayor, goes out to lay asphalt because the craftsmen and workers have been negligent, who will fulfil the mayor’s role? A craftsman and a worker? But will they be able to, if there is already a job — their own job — in which they have proved incompetent? Can they demonstrate competence in a job that is not their own? You can move on to something else, but first you need to become competent in your own work; there is greater potential for development here.

A worker’s labour is just as important. If your toilet springs a leak and the plumber decides to wage war on it or on you, to haggle or establish power over you, that is unlikely to make things any easier for you or your home — or, indeed, for the toilet. Right? And what if we are talking about the sewerage system of an entire city? Or some other system? In recent years, the city of Novosibirsk has been engulfed in smells, dirt and stench… Perhaps because someone is not fulfilling their roles, having got something mixed up?
Being a worker does not mean belonging to a ‘lower caste’. India’s caste system was not about that at all. On the one hand, it has a static aspect; on the other, a dynamic one. In its static form, that is, its hierarchy, those who hold power (Kshatriyas) and knowledge (Brahmins) occupy a certain position because some provide knowledge, a great deal of knowledge (and bear an enormous responsibility for this), while others bear an enormous responsibility and devote their entire lives to serving thousands, hundreds of thousands and millions of people. But if we imagine this system dynamically, as a wheel, it turns out that at any given time and in any given place (the wheel moves through time and space), any of the 4 castes can take the leading role. If a management decision is needed, the ruler takes the lead. If protection is needed, warriors matter. If goods, services and crafts are needed, Vaishyas take the lead. If knowledge and spirituality are needed, Brahmins come to the fore, and if there are problems with rubbish or snow in the city (after heavy snowfall), workers are now No. 1.
So the caste system was conceived not as a system for dividing people into higher and lower ranks, but as a system for effectively managing a group of people in a territory, serving as a balancing tool that maintains a constructive equilibrium.

Take a business example. A hotel. The general manager bears enormous responsibility and makes major decisions to ensure the satisfaction of customers and staff, as well as other stakeholders such as the tax authorities, inspection bodies and so on. The warriors are the security team and lawyers; the administrators are department heads and the general manager’s deputies. Craftsmen (Vaishyas) include, for example, chefs; traders are the sales department, call centre and reception. Brahmins are the HR department and training centre, and all the mentors. And the workers are the room attendants and laundry staff, without whom a comfortable hotel is impossible!

The question arises: why does pay differ, if everyone is important? Everyone is important, but there are levels of responsibility. Those with greater responsibility receive greater rewards. That is all.

What happens if the general manager goes to work in place of a room attendant (not as part of induction into the role), while the groundskeeper takes his chair? If the lawyer works at reception and the accountant goes to the sales department? If the chef heads off to accounts and his assistant takes the lawyer’s chair — after all, he knows how to handle a knife. And if the security team sits down to do the call centre staff’s work?

Originally, the caste system was quite flexible and wise; that was how it was conceived. In essence, it is about everyone understanding their role in this world, in their country, their region and a particular company, based on their personal interests and preferences, abilities and talents. And about setting priorities wisely when choosing a particular path for a particular period of time. Everyone carries all the roles within them, but one will predominate, and it is very important to use the other roles to support the priority role, not the other way round. That is what this is about. Then the person in the ruler’s chair will serve his country and his people, warriors will protect it, teachers will teach, craftsmen will do their work well, traders will help craftsmen sell, and workers will create the conditions and opportunities for an effective and comfortable life for themselves and everyone else. Having achieved certain results, you can, if you wish (though you do not have to), move a step higher (professional mastery is what we are talking about) or choose another path — that is normal. And we know examples of this both in history and in individual companies.

Inheritance. It was not there originally. It emerged later, because the meaning of the roles became distorted. A ruler… wants to pass power on to his child, not because the child can be a ruler (what if he is a worker or a craftsman?), but because he wants to give the child the benefits that come with this role, forgetting that they are the result of his responsibility. He does not consider whether the child is ready to bear such responsibility. History offers many such examples. And that is why India has a figure such as Bharata, whose wisdom so many generations admire and remember. Although they do not always follow it. The ruler had the inner courage to act wisely rather than follow 2 very strong attachments in anyone’s life — benefits and children.

Now let us turn to question 1. Does a business trainer have to be a successful businessperson? What do you think now?
The ruler — service and governance; the warrior — protection and duty; the craftsman — creativity, usefulness and mastery; the trader — relationships and money; the worker — usefulness and the conditions for successful activity; and the Brahmin — spirituality and knowledge.

The first things a business trainer must master are knowledge and the ability to pass it on. If, after some time, he wants to fulfil himself in another category, he can do so, and if he also manages to combine the two, that means he had a strong desire to do this and the potential for different roles in this world. But is he obliged to do so? No.
Take an analogy. How would you assess a surgeon’s effectiveness? By the number of clinics he owns and the money in his account, or by the number of patients who survive and, preferably, are healthy? What would come first for you? The same applies to members of the teaching profession, which can take different forms — from a schoolteacher to a business trainer and onwards to a spiritual teacher, a worthy representative of a particular faith, religion and so on.

A business trainer is a mini-version of a teacher. It is a step on a vast journey. Looking at the caste system, let us imagine a Spiritual Teacher–Trader… This does not mean a teacher should work for free. Those to whom he gives knowledge, who receive knowledge from him, thank him, including with money. But trading is not his priority. Otherwise, this would be trading in spirituality. And spirituality cannot be bought, although the teacher is thanked, preferably adequately (otherwise he will have to do something else). Again, history offers examples — the famous indulgence… Osho, with his Rolls-Royces, gave a very serious ‘hint’ at the heart of the matter. So you should look for a business trainer or teacher not by the amount of money in his account, the number of businesses he owns or the size of his business, but by the breadth and level of knowledge in his head. Just as you should look for a worker by his skills, a craftsman by his mastery, a warrior by his sense of duty, a ruler by his devotion to his country, and a trader by his ability to build relationships and, of course, by his money.

What do the diagrams show? A balance of priorities. When you understand your current role, it takes the dominant position, and all the other roles support it (they are smaller), not the other way round. Why? To fulfil any role, you need all the others. Yes, one supporting role may be larger than the others at a particular time, in a particular situation; then a second may take its place, and then a third. But however they alternate (as appropriate to time and place, that is, the situation), they always support the main role.

And to keep priorities in balance at all times, wisdom is needed, which (again, originally, not later, when the system was ‘reworked’) does not depend on the role (caste) a person occupies… It depends only on that person’s level of development.

Look around. You will see everything written here. And you will also see the consequences of upsetting the balance of priorities. In the world, in countries, in cities, in companies and in people’s lives.

_xOrOP0vM1QSVRasiPY3XnHNR-CT1DjnsfhFAvb7hWmxJrOgW4NG61WtxGhua9MYnBfLZ6-u-pi7osZIiyKNOnbn.jpg
CXLvMIlMkuNq_BV3YoSGWMzZuVh1Agf7T5RRsCCNEqiDlc3BLhByOuE4bZBGtJ6cEf56ZKO6L6fdvWt9acOVH8f4.jpg

Tatyana Arzhaeva, TSC Development Lab


← Personal Effectiveness

Contact us
Order a book